There are many very poorly written articles in Wikipedia. This does not make it a poor resource; it just makes it a starting point to be viewed extremely skeptically, as every resource should be viewed.
But a good example of a bad article on so many levels is the History of Martinique. Even if you ignore the uncorrected vandalism, it's just... bad. Bad writing, unsourced, inaccurate, even plain wrong.
en.WN
Just this goy...
Saturday, February 10, 2007
Thomas Edison was born(he sdfgsdfgsdfg sdf in Milan, Ohio, the seventh and last child of Samuel Ogden Edison, Jr. (1804–1896) (born in Marshalltown, Nova Scotia, Canada) and the former Nancy Matthews Elliott (1810–1871).
And thus spake Zarathustra in [[Thomas Edison]], and yet I cannot find this edit in the history of the article.
Thursday, February 08, 2007
Pointless.
It contains no verifiable information, no link to a relevant Wikipedia article.
1998 - A college dropout becomes the first person to be convicted of a hate crime committed in cyberspace. (10 February)
It contains no verifiable information, no link to a relevant Wikipedia article.
Wednesday, February 07, 2007
Gotta love advertisements in day's history...
Lovely. Yet again the edit has been oversighted, only in this case there is no possible justification for it.
2007 David Lam and the Pistols takes on Tommy in the Geno Bowl (9 February)
Lovely. Yet again the edit has been oversighted, only in this case there is no possible justification for it.
Tuesday, February 06, 2007
Very strange... I clipped this from 7 Feb. on Wikipedia:
to comment on it. Now I cannot find it anywhere in the article's history. One presumes it has been deleted from the history using Oversight. The reason being there was a person's real name where the Xs are. What bothers me is not that it was done, but that it happened so rapidly. It suggests that not only is Oversight used regularly, it's "instant on", with no questions being asked.
1986 - XXXXXXXXXXX, Malaysian student
to comment on it. Now I cannot find it anywhere in the article's history. One presumes it has been deleted from the history using Oversight. The reason being there was a person's real name where the Xs are. What bothers me is not that it was done, but that it happened so rapidly. It suggests that not only is Oversight used regularly, it's "instant on", with no questions being asked.
Blog roll
-
-
Review: In My Father's Country13 years ago
-
A piece of cake15 years ago
About Me
- Amgine
- Owned by Njørđson, a Cape Dory 25D.